1. USA
  2. California
  3. San Diego
  4. Shelter Island
  5. Beach Home Rentals

Shelter Island Beach House Rentals & Places to Stay

Find the best beach rentals in Shelter Island - We found 729 exact matches

About Shelter Island Beach Home Rentals on Online Reservations

Looking for a cottage rental, lake house, or summer homes near Shelter Island? Online Reservations features more than 729 villas, beach hotels, and private rentals that are perfect for your next beach vacation. Discover luxury beach resorts and rentals that are within walking distance from Shelter Island. Premium stays near the beach in Shelter Island are kid-friendly & family-friendly, and are near top local attraction spots, to give guests an unforgettable travel experience. Online Reservations's listings come in all shapes and sizes for large groups, friends, couples, or wedding retreats in Shelter Island.

Online Reservations offers 729 high-end holiday homes, villas, and great places to stay in Shelter Island. The site provides unique Airbnb-style accommodations as well as hotels and resorts to make your trip with friends and family something you'll never forget.

Online Reservations beachfront places to stay give you the best travel experience that makes it easy to find and book the best stays at the best destinations.Plan Your Perfect Escape with Online Reservations.

Show more
Show less

Frequently Asked Questions About Shelter Island Beach Rentals

There are a lot of options in Shelter Island. If you plan on staying in the Shelter Island area, consider making a reservation for a few nights at one of these properties as these have been rated the top Beach Home Rentals in Shelter Island:

The average cost for a beach rental in Shelter Island is $451 per night. Online Reservations has a wide assortment of great beachfront homes near Shelter Island that would suit your needs.
Yes, we have 729 beach rentals with pools available in Shelter Island. Check our search bar to find a selection of vacation rentals available near Shelter Island.
Yes, here are the top beach rentals in Shelter Island that allow you to bring your pet:

See all pet-friendly beach rentals in Shelter Island on Online Reservations

Most of the beach rentals we list are suitable for families or groups. Check out the complete list of the beach houses in Shelter Island to find one that works for you.
As of 2025, the data from Online Reservations shows that there are over 729 properties with private swimming pools or private homes with indoor pools in the Shelter Island area.
About 729 properties in Shelter Island boast of having access to hot tubs.