293+ Vacation Rentals & Holiday Homes in Menantic Creek |
  1. USA
  2. New York
  3. Shelter Island
  4. Menantic Creek

Menantic Creek Accommodations - Hotels & Rentals

About Menantic Creek Vacation Rentals

Discover More than 293 Incredible Getaway Rentals Available in Menantic Creek. Choose from a Wide Selection of Villas, Hotels, and Other Rental Options. Explore Luxury Amenities at Affordable Prices, Creating the Ideal Base for Your Next Vacation. Plan Your Perfect Escape with Online Reservations and Uncover Fantastic Stays in Menantic Creek.

Online Reservations Offers Numerous Last-Minute Deals on Villas, Hotels, and Rentals, Both Near You and Across the Globe. Whether You Need Accommodation for a Group or an Event, Be it a Hotel or Vacation Rental (Including Cabins and Private Luxury Villas), We're Here to Assist. With Online Reservations in Menantic Creek, You Can Easily Compare Options from Multiple Suppliers with a Single Click to Find the Perfect Price Point, Amenities, and Style of Stay That Suit Your Needs. Looking for Group Deals, Properties with Private Pools, Hot Tubs, Pet-Friendly Options, or Spacious Master Suite Bedrooms with Open-Air Showers? You Can Find It All in the Online Reservations Vacation Rentals, Resorts, and Airbnb-Style Properties in Menantic Creek. The Average Size of Places to Stay Near Menantic Creek is 1182.37 ft², with Prices Averaging US $1,060 per Night.

Let Online Reservations Help You Discover the Ideal Holiday Rental to Create Lifelong Travel Memories in Menantic Creek. Our Listed Prices Are Often Discounted Compared to Rack Rates. Simply Search for Your Destination and Secure the Perfect Place to Stay Today.

Show more
Show less

Top Hotels & Vacation Rentals in Menantic Creek

Type Count
Vacation Homes 242
Cottages 14
Holiday Apartments 7

Use these Quick Filters to Find a Vacation Rental in Menantic Creek

★ Pro Tip: Online Reservations is a vacation rental website specializing in cottages, lake houses, and exclusive summer home rentals. We curate a vast selection of incredible properties from trusted suppliers, allowing you to compare prices and locations to find the perfect fit for your getaway. Create lasting memories in Menantic Creek with Online Reservations.

Weather in Menantic Creek, NY

View the weather forecast for Menantic Creek before booking your Menantic Creek Vacation Rentals to confirm your best time to go.

December - February
High 60°F       Low 26°F
March - May
High 77°F       Low 40°F
June - August
High 91°F       Low 64°F
September - November
High 84°F       Low 38°F

Frequently Asked Questions About Menantic Creek?

What are the top hotels, lake houses & vacation rentals in Menantic Creek?

We provide an array of great vacation destinations in Menantic Creek. If you are looking to stay in or around the Menantic Creek area, make sure to browse our options to find a premium rental location in a top vacation destination. Whether it is a few nights, a week, or more, we've got the luxury stays that rank among the Top Vacation Rentals in Menantic Creek:

How many Hotels & Vacation Rentals have private pools in Menantic Creek?

We have 80 Hotels & Vacation Rentals featuring a private pool in and near Menantic Creek. Some of the best destinations to stay that feature or have access to a swimming pool are:

Which hotel, lake house, or vacation rental in Menantic Creek is best for families?

Searching for a family-friendly getaway in Menantic Creek? We've got you covered. Check out one of these luxurious getaways that are highly-rated and perfect fits for families of all sizes.

How many hotels, resorts, or rentals are available in Menantic Creek?

Online Reservations™ offers a consistent supply of new options, combined with established great stays in top areas. Currently, the number of properties listed by Online Reservations™ in 2025 is over 293 in the Menantic Creek area, and that number rises every day. By combining listings from multiple websites and travel providers, Online Reservations™ can provide you with a diverse amount of choices of the best luxury stays in Menantic Creek.

Nearby Neighborhood (1) 
Neighborhood Property Count
Montclair Colony Vacation Rentals in Shelter Island, New York 197

People Also Ask

Online Reservation in Menantic Creek

Recently Booked Hotels, Resorts, or Rentals in Menantic Creek